Categories
Videos

On bowling balls, hammers, and feathers

“To develop working ideas efficiently, I try to fail as fast as I can.” — Richard Feynman

Aristotle (384–322 BCE) argued that if the void existed, every object would fall through the void at the same unlimited speed, because there would be nothing to hinder its motion. Therefore, Aristotle concluded, the concept of the void is absurd. This was one of several arguments he gave for its nonexistence. Over eight centuries later, John Philoponus (Approx 490-570 CE) thought otherwise. He lived over a thousand years before Galileo, and his works of critical commentary on Aristotle’s physics were largely forgotten for many centuries.

So, what actually happens when you drop a feather and a bowling ball in vacuum? Here is a full-scale demonstration, carried out in the world’s largest vacuum chamber:

An earlier demonstration was carried out on the Moon using a hammer and a feather by Apollo 15 astronaut David Scott:

Categories
Videos

Space Oddity on the ISS

This video has received over 30 millions views since the astronaut Chris Hadfield posted it in 2013. David Bowie considers it the ‘most poignant’ cover of his song.

A perfect example the Equivalence Principle in action, and a good intro to our discussion of local frames, the General Theory of Relativity, and so forth…

Categories
Essays Web sites

Einstein and the Nobel Prize

einstein

Einstein won the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1921 for his work on the photoelectric effect, where he first introduced the notion that light was composed of discrete particles he called ‘photons’. However, his Nobel Lecture concerns the Theory of Relativity.  By this time the Special Theory had received experimental confirmation, yet apparently not enough for some members of the Prize Committee. The General Theory was considered still more speculative at this time, even though the precession of the perihelion of Mercury was correctly predicted by the theory, and the bending of starlight had been observed by Eddington’s solar eclipse expedition of 1919.

There is a wealth of understatement in the description given in the prize announcement, as summarized on the Nobel Prize website linked above:

“The Nobel Prize in Physics 1921 was awarded to Albert Einstein “for his services to Theoretical Physics, and especially for his discovery of the law of the photoelectric effect”.

Albert Einstein received his Nobel Prize one year later, in 1922. During the selection process in 1921, the Nobel Committee for Physics decided that none of the year’s nominations met the criteria as outlined in the will of Alfred Nobel. According to the Nobel Foundation’s statutes, the Nobel Prize can in such a case be reserved until the following year, and this statute was then applied. Albert Einstein therefore received his Nobel Prize for 1921 one year later, in 1922.”

Relativity was still considered a controversial theory in some quarters, even though it had largely been embraced by the leading theoretical physicists. The ‘relativity revolution’ was still underway, and sill incomplete.

A complete bibliography of Einstein’s publications prior to 1922 can be found here. Although many of the titles are in German, it is clear that his early work was on the fundamentals of thermodynamics and statistical physics, and only in 1905 does he begin to publish work on what we now call the Special Theory of Relativity.

For a recent review of tests of the Special and General Theories, see the 2006 article by Clifford Will.

einstein_office_photo

Categories
Discussion topics

Do the past and the future exist, or only ‘now’?

1920px-Old_book_bindings

Cosmology Folks: I am going to try an experiment tomorrow and need your help.

When you arrive in class, please arrange yourselves into small groups of from 2-3 students each. Then, with your colleagues, please discuss the following: Newton’s theory of Absolute Space and Absolute Time, implies the concept of a Universal Now. In Newton’s view, each Universal Now is like a page in a book, and ‘eternity’ is like the entire stack of pages that make up the book. The analogy is not perfect, because Newton believed time is continuous, but you get the idea.

Here is Mel Brooks’ take on it, from the movie Spaceballs.

Question: Does the future already exist, and does the past still exist? (This type of theory is called the Block Universe.) If the past and future all exist, not just ‘Now’, why do we only experience a single Now? Please discuss…

See you tomorrow (aka the next page in Newton’s book).